NEWS

Protecting Fox Lake’s Heritage

Continuing preservation efforts, new documentary showcase historic Black resort community

Near Angola, Project 250 recognizes Fox Lake, a historic African American resort community. The area retains historic cottages, including Pryor’s Country Place (above), a former inn recently rehabbed by preservation-minded owners. PHOTO: Courtesy Ringenberg Family

To celebrate the 250th anniversary of the United States in 2026, Indiana Landmarks’ Black Heritage Preservation Program began Project 250, a community-based initiative to document 250 significant Black heritage sites across the state—all illuminating different aspects of Black history in Indiana and providing a foundation for future research that will help Indiana Landmarks identify, recognize, and preserve significant places.

Lakeside Legacy

In the 1920s, at a time when segregation limited recreation opportunities for African Americans, Fox Lake developed near Angola as a place where Black families could vacation. Today, it remains one of the nation’s few surviving historic Black resort communities, where lakeside cottages and natural areas still provide a retreat for residents and summer visitors.

Concerned that overdevelopment could change the nature of the lakefront community, property owners formed Fox Lake Preservation Foundation in 2020 to help protect the community’s natural character and cultural heritage. Since then, the foundation has promoted educational initiatives to share Fox Lake’s history while serving as a preservation resource for owners of its historic cottages. Earlier this year, Fox Lake’s National Register-listed historic district was expanded to encompass the entire lake. With grant funding from Indiana Landmarks’ Black Heritage Preservation Program, the foundation hired preservation consultant Kurt Garner to prepare the nomination, including later structures such as the 1968 K.T. Thompson Lodge and Mar-Fran Motel.

This year, Fox Lake’s National Register-listed historic district expanded to encompass the entire lake and later structures, including the 1968 K.T. Thompson Lodge. Photo by Carol Karst-Wasson

As the community looks to celebrate its centennial in 2027-28, the foundation recruited filmmaker Stefon Whitaker to create Summertime Sanctuary, a documentary exploring Fox Lake’s rich history. An Angola native, Whitaker holds personal ties to Fox Lake through his own childhood experiences at the lake and through his mother, who worked in her teens at the lake’s Mar-Fran Motel. Whitaker has begun interviewing property owners and families with longtime connections to the community and gathering archival photos for the project, which remains in the production and fundraising stages.

One of Fox Lake’s historic landmarks recognized through Indiana Landmarks’ Project 250 is Pryor’s Country Place, a 1916 home that was converted to an inn in the 1940s, offering seasonal accommodation to vacationers and earning listing in the Negro Motorist Green Book, an influential guide published from 1936 to 1966 that identified destinations friendly to African American travelers. The Craftsman home appeared on Indiana Landmarks’ 10 Most Endangered list in 2016 when it was put up for sale, its prime lakeside location raising concerns about potential development plans. Fortunately, the house found the right preservation-minded buyers in Mark and Martha Ringenberg in 2020.

Mark and Martha Ringenberg purchased Pryor's Country Place in 2020 and began rehabbing the historic cottage to bring back its historic character. PHOTOS: Courtesy Ringenberg Family

Looking for a lakeside retreat of their own, the Ringenbergs were charmed by Fox Lake’s peaceful setting and saw potential in Pryor’s Country Place, even as they quickly realized it would require comprehensive restoration. Living in a camper on site, the couple began the painstaking work of gutting the interior, replacing the roof, and addressing the extensive damage, refuse, and a pervasive stench left by raccoons that had overtaken the property. Since the house had been remodeled multiple times to accommodate guests, the Ringenbergs worked to restore room dimensions and design elements consistent with the house’s Arts and Crafts character, guided by their daughter Audra DeSelm, who holds a degree in interior design.

The couple reused and repurposed original materials whenever possible while incorporating salvaged architectural elements and furnishings sourced from resale shops. Joy Parker, a member of the Pryor family who grew up in the house, offered the Ringenbergs valuable insights into the property’s history, including gifting them a guest book maintained by her mother with comments from former visitors. Individually listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 2024, the restored house now serves as the family’s lakeside retreat and occasional vacation rental.

“Joy and Hal Parker are the true stewards of this property’s history. They had chances to sell it for more money, but prospective buyers weren’t interested in preserving it. That’s ultimately how we got it,” says Mark Ringenberg. “Joy told us her parents would be so happy to see what we’ve done.”

Learn more about Fox Lake Preservation Foundation on their website, foxlakeflpo.org, and about the Fox Lake Summertime Sanctuary documentary at foxlakein.com/summertime-sanctuary and on their Facebook page.

This article first appeared in the November/December 2026 issue of Indiana Preservation, Indiana Landmarks’ member magazine.

Sign up for our e-newsletter.

Stay up to date on the latest news, stories, and events from Indiana Landmarks, around the state or in your area.