NEWS
Historic Settlement Highlights Early Black Pioneers
Nonprofit owner protects Roberts Settlement’s heritage through preservation of its historic chapel and educational displays
To celebrate the 250th anniversary of the United States in 2026, Indiana Landmarks’ Black Heritage Preservation Program began Project 250, a community-based initiative to document 250 significant Black heritage sites across the state—all illuminating different aspects of Black history in Indiana and providing a foundation for future research that will help Indiana Landmarks identify, recognize, and preserve significant places.
Coming Home
In northern Hamilton County, Indiana Landmarks’ Project 250 highlights Roberts Settlement, a rural farm community established in 1835 by free people of color who migrated from North Carolina and Virginia before settling near abolitionist Quaker and anti-slavery Methodist communities in the area. Today, an 1858 chapel, two historic cemeteries, and a handful of houses tell the story of these early pioneers.
Though no longer used for regular services, Roberts Chapel remains the heart of the community, drawing former residents and their descendants back each year for homecoming events, a Fourth of July tradition dating to 1924. Recognizing the site’s significance early on, community members formed the nonprofit Roberts Chapel Homecoming and Burial Association in 1938 to preserve the chapel and adjacent cemetery.
Indiana Landmarks has supported those efforts for years, including providing funding to identify preservation priorities and helping secure grants from the Standiford H. Cox Fund of the Central Indiana Community Foundation. Most recently, that support helped fund repairs to the chapel’s foundation, belfry, and bell. With ongoing improvements, the association aims to expand Roberts Chapel’s role as a gathering place for community events and educational programs.
In 2024, aided by grant funding from the Hamilton County Community Foundation, Hamilton County Tourism, and the National Trust for Historic Preservation’s Preserving Black Churches program, the association unveiled the Legacy Walk, an accessible pathway featuring exhibits along the chapel’s west side, introducing visitors to the settlement’s history and Indiana’s Black pioneers. With the addition of Legacy Gardens this year, the path offers a peaceful space for learning and reflection.
“If you look back at the original articles of formation for the burial association, the trustees said history was to be preserved and this story was to be told,” says Bryan Glover, a Roberts Settlement descendant and board trustee. “I think every generation since then has done its part to keep this history alive for the next generation.”
“We are so blessed to be on the shoulders of our ancestors, through whose great vision and perseverance we could see who we could become through them,” adds LaVella Hyter, a descendant and board president. “Roberts Settlement is a great learning ground and beautiful community.”
Learn more about Roberts Settlement on their website, robertssettlement.org.
This article first appeared in the November/December 2026 issue of Indiana Preservation, Indiana Landmarks’ member magazine.
Stay up to date on the latest news, stories, and events from Indiana Landmarks, around the state or in your area.
